Posted 31 July 2025 - 09:20 AM
Dear Rmccabe,
What is tacky is including the wording in the invitation that the couple would appreciate gift cards. This is the same as asking for cash.
Although it is becoming more common to give gift cards for a shower, it really isn't proper. The traditional gift giving shower involves gifts that are to be opened. You could give them something you wish to give that is not on a registry.
The gift-less shower would have been much more proper in this case. It is a bit stomach turning to hear of a couple expecting their guest to assist them with the building of their new home just because they decided to marry.
There is no appropriate amount for any gift. One amount is generous to some and yet lacking to another. If these people expect gift cards, they probably expect their guests to give them a large sum.
Best wishes,